Call Us TODAY on 020 3588 4240

Writ of Control | When Goods Belong to the “Significant Other” | What Next?

Entering a CCJ against a named individual or sole trader often raises the problem of the goods of that person being owned wholly or partly by their “significant other”. Where it is their spouse, their life partner, or some other form of co-ownership you need to be aware that this creates the proverbial “spanner in the works” when it comes to enforcing your judgment.

 

A claim by a co-owner has to be dealt with. It can’t be ignored however unlikely it seems, but it doesn’t actually stop the enforcement process.

 

The Position of the Co-Owner in Relation to the Goods

The enforcement strategy for engaging a High Court Enforcement Officer, is one of taking the goods of the Judgment Debtor into legal control, to compel payment of the Court’s Judgment or Award.

 

When the High Court Enforcement Agent reaches the address on the Writ it is possible that a husband, wife, or partner may answer the door and say that the Judgment Debtor doesn’t own the goods or that they own them 50/50. We rarely seem a “significant other” claiming a percentage of more or less than 50%.

 

Both the Judgment Debtor and any co-owner may think that as the goods are not wholly owned by the Judgment Debtor, they somehow escape the enforcement process and are “exempt” from being taken into legal control.

 

However, the law says otherwise. Co-owned goods can be taken into legal control, and the claim of the “significant other” can be dealt with as a Third-Party Claim to Goods Taken into Legal Control, under the Civil Procedure Rules – see CPR Part 85.

 

So, unless the “significant other” is named as a Judgment Debtor on the Writ of Control, they will not be liable for the debt, but their goods could be at risk of being taken and sold.

 

Managing Third-Party Claims

If a claim by a “significant other” is made at the time of attendance, or 3 days later, then the High Court Enforcement Agent has to report this back to the High Court Enforcement Officer who must process it in accordance with requirements of CPR Part 85.

 

This means the claim of co-ownership must be sent to the Judgment Creditor to either accept or dispute this claim.

 

If the claim is accepted, then the goods (other than exempt goods) can be removed from the Judgment Debtor’s address and sold to satisfy the Judgment Debtor’s share of the debt.

If the goods are held jointly then 50% of the proceeds will be used to pay off the amount due under the Writ, leaving the other 50% being returned to the co-owner.

 

If the Judgment Creditor disputes the claim by the Third Party to their interest in the goods, then either the Third Party or the High Court Enforcement Officer can issue an application to have the question of ownership dealt with before the Court. The Court will be asked to decide on the question of ownership and how the sale should proceed.

 

Weighing Up the Decision to Dispute A Co-Owner’s Claim to Ownership

Third-Party claims to goods are the proverbial “spanner” in the enforcement process and must be taken seriously.

 

The value of the goods taken into legal control will often determine the way the third party’s claim will proceed.

 

Where goods are valuable, a co-owner can expect a Judgment Creditor to look carefully at the claim to ownership and weigh up if the Third Party’s claim is supported by evidence in the form of bank statements showing the Third Party’s funds or joint funds being used to purchase the goods.

A sensible Judgment Creditor will be persuaded by evidence of ownership and either pursue a sale of the valuable items to clear the value outstanding under the judgment or accept that the co-owner owns the goods 100% in his or her own right, and the Judgment Debtor has no interest in them.

 

The High Court Enforcement Officer plays an important role in helping the parties to understand their respective positions and taking sensible commercial decisions.

 

Where the goods are not valuable, then the parties should look carefully at the cost of disputing the co-owners claim to either a share or full ownership. Taking control of goods and selling them to liquidate the Judgment Debtor’s share in the goods may work, but 50% of the sale proceeds will have to go back to the co-owner.

 

Summing Up

You can tell from reading this blog that the appearance of a claim by a “significant other” in the enforcement process can chuck a spanner in the works.

 

Ways to stop this happening start right at the outset of your dealings with an individual or sole trader. Where you are supplying to a customer check out if it is a “spouse and spouse” team or co-owners – and put that person’s name on your invoice, and then add them into the claim and then they will appear on your judgment.

 

A credit application at the outset of supplying goods and/or services is a great way to find out information about who your customer is before you start trading.

 

Of course, not all judgments are based on contract, so this may only help some of you reading this blog.

 

If you find yourself bumping into a third-party claim, then you can talk to us about your options and we can advise you on how to get the best from the situation. Just remember the less value in the goods, the less likely you are to come away with a paid in full Writ – unfortunately.

 

Talk to us on 0845 890 9200 or email us at [email protected] if you need more help on this aspect of enforcement.

 
Content Writer​

DISCLAIMER NOTICE |

The following disclaimer applies to Shergroup Limited and its platform, shergroup.com. Please read this notice carefully before accessing or using any information provided on our platform.

  1. No Legal Advice | The information presented on shergroup.com, including but not limited to articles, blog posts, FAQs, and other resources, is provided for general informational purposes only. It is not intended to be, and should not be considered, legal advice. The information provided does not create a solicitor/client relationship between Shergroup Limited and the user.
  2. Not a Substitute for Legal Advice | The information on shergroup.com should not be relied upon as a substitute for obtaining legal advice from a qualified professional. The application of laws and regulations can vary based on specific circumstances, and legal advice tailored to your particular situation is crucial. Therefore, we may refer you to a member of our partner firm -Shergroup Legal – on legal matters or encourage you to take your own legal advice from your preferred advisor.
  3. No Guarantee of Accuracy | While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, Shergroup Limited does not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or reliability of any information on shergroup.com. The legal landscape is constantly evolving, and laws may vary across jurisdictions. Therefore, any reliance you place on the information provided is at your own risk.
  4. No Liability | Shergroup Limited, including its officers, employees, agents, and affiliates, shall not be held liable for any direct, indirect, incidental, consequential, or punitive damages arising out of your access to or use of shergroup.com or any information contained therein. This includes, but is not limited to, any errors or omissions in the content, or any actions taken or not taken based on the information provided.
  5. Third-Party Links | Shergroup.com may contain links to third-party websites or resources. These links are provided solely for convenience and do not imply endorsement or responsibility for the content, accuracy, or legality of such websites or resources. Shergroup Limited shall not be liable for any damages or losses incurred as a result of accessing or using any third-party websites or resources.
  6. Changes to Disclaimer | Shergroup Limited reserves the right to modify or amend this disclaimer notice at any time without prior notice. Any changes will be effective immediately upon posting on shergroup.com. It is your responsibility to review this notice periodically for updates.

By accessing or using shergroup.com, you acknowledge that you have read, understood, and agreed to this disclaimer notice. If you do not agree with any part of this notice, you should refrain from accessing or using shergroup.com.

Last updated | 19 July 2023

Should you have any questions or concerns regarding this disclaimer notice, please contact us at [email protected]